Was it only two years ago that seemingly quixotic ballot issue effort was underway to expand Medicaid health insurance in Idaho?
It seemed like an improbable thing. Nearly all of the elected officials in Idaho who had anything to say about the Affordable Care Act, of which Medicaid expansion was a critical piece, were heaping abuse on it at every opportunity.
The intensity of the opposition among the state’s political leadership at least was overwhelming, which should have been an indicator that expansion just wasn’t likely to happen, even at the voter level, right?
But it didn’t work out that way. Medicaid expansion not only passed among the Idaho voters, it passed in a landslide. And while the legislature fought back, a modified version of it is now going on the books and coming into place. Apparently, at least.
Legalized medical marijuana, the subject of an intensive petition drive, must seem about as improbable now as Medicaid did then. But the state’s Medicaid experience tells us this: Don’t write off the prospects that it will go on the Idaho books.
While the Affordable Care Act never polled massively well in Idaho (probably it does better now than it did six or eight years ago), Medicaid expansion in recent years at least consistently polled well. While complete marijuana legalization still does not poll well in Idaho, medical marijuana does; well enough to suggest that a narrowly-crafted measure to legalize and regulate it would have a decent chance of passage if it reaches the ballot in November next year.
Will it reach the ballot? The effort already has cleared several bars, and the petition signature process is underway; it will continue until next spring. Getting any issue on the ballot in Idaho these days requires an excellent level of organization and energy. The Medicaid expansion campaign was unusually well organized and did a terrific job; it will not be easy to replicate. But it also created a template, a specific set of steps and plan of attack that other ballot issue campaigns could use in the future. Such as medical marijuana, this year.
Backers need to collect more than 55,000 signatures, distributed around the state in specific ways. That makes the effort more difficult, but—and this was a lesson coming out of Medicaid expansion—it also means that if organizers do develop a powerful and thorough enough campaign to get that done, they also have developed a strong enough campaign to sell the case affirmatively to the voters.
The case also has another advantage: Earlier adoption by neighboring states. By the time Idaho voters got to decide on Medicaid expansion, they could look around and see a number of nearby states that already had taken action on that front, and found no great negatives accruing. In the case of medical marijuana, most of the states bordering Idaho already have taken the legalize-and-regulate route (which resembles what Idaho does with alcohol), and while there are some problems the skies have not fallen in. In southwest Idaho, residents are seeing regular visits between the Boise metro area and the city of Ontario, less than an hour away, as Idahoans buy what they want and can’t buy (legally) at home.
The same thing happens in other border areas. None of this is going unnoticed by Idaho voters.
If the measure does make the ballot and does pass, many legislators would no doubt want to take an ax to it at the next legislative session. But they might have cause to hesitate. The effort by legislators this year to undermine the will of a landslide portion of Idaho voters, followed by an effort to virtually kill off the initiative process in Idaho, has led to some backlash. If on top of that a majority of Idaho voters choose to legalize medical marijuana, and legislators move to repeal it, what might be the political impact of that?
Imagine opposition to a marijuana liberalization law as the basis for a serious political threat to Idaho legislators. As unlikely as it sounds, the pieces for that could be coming together.
That’s down the road, of course. The legalization advocates have a long way to go before all that could happen.
But as the Medicaid expansion activists would tell you, never write off an effort backed by enough people.
Catch the latest in Opinion
Get opinion pieces, letters and editorials sent directly to your inbox weekly!