Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Edit
alert
Idaho View

Idaho View: Even in Idaho, the Big Lie is a big lie

  • 4
Boxes of ballots

Boxes of ballots are wheeled in to be counted as part of a recount at the Clark County Election Department in Las Vegas on Monday, Dec. 07, 2020. (Daniel Clark/The Nevada Independent)

If the Big Lie didn’t happen in Idaho, then it probably didn’t happen anywhere else.

That’s because when the same fellow who alleged fraud robbed former President Donald Trump of victory over President Joe Biden — “My Pillow Guy” Mike Lindell — leveled the same exact charge at Idaho, Republican Secretary of State Lawerence Denney debunked it.

A webpage tied to Lindell asserts widespread fraud stole a 6 million vote win from Trump and handed a 7 million vote victory to Biden. It alleges the tactic flipped eight states to Biden:

l Arizona — Biden won it by 10,457 votes; the webpage says Trump won by 269,979 votes.

l Georgia — Biden won it by 11,779 votes; the webpage says Trump’s margin was 403,265 votes.

l Michigan — Biden’s 154,188 vote margin actually was a 304,536 vote win for Trump.

l Minnesota — Biden’s 233,012 vote win dissolves into a 36,194 vote margin for Trump.

l Nevada — Biden got 33,596 more votes; the webpage says it was really a 81,920 vote victory for Trump.

l New Hampshire — Biden’s 59,277 vote edge morphs into a 6,989-vote win for Trump.

l Pennsylvania — Biden won it by 80,555 votes; the webpage puts it in Trump’s column with a 494,429 vote margin.

Idaho was as solidly for Trump as any state in the union. The former president got nearly 64 percent of the vote compared to 33 percent for Biden.

But even that wasn’t enough for the Lindell webpage. It asserts that election irregularities in the reddest of red states deprived Trump of more than 35,000 votes — and fraudulently added nearly 71,000 votes to Biden’s tally.

What grabbed the secretary of state’s attention were some obvious fallacies:

l The skullduggery was the result of hacking tabulation machines. Two problems with that: First, seven of Idaho’s counties do not have tabulation machines. They tally the results on a paper ledger. And the machines themselves are the equivalent of a closed-circuit television; they are linked to each other, not the internet. (That’s pretty much the case across the country.)

l The webpage gets a lot of other things wrong. For instance, it timed the hack in Payette County at 1:52 a.m. on Nov. 3, 2020 — almost six hours before voting actually commenced.

l A standardized formula explains every discrepancy the webpage assigns to all 44 Idaho counties. First, it disregards the five third-party candidates and write-ins who collectively took 3.1 percent. Then it multiplies the Biden-Trump tally by the same fraction and rounds down to the next smallest number.

Denney and his chief deputy, Chad Houck, looked over the results in three other states — Alabama, New York and Utah — and identified the same technique.

Arizona's Controversial, Election Review, Confirms Biden's Win. A GOP-led review of the 2020 election in Arizona's largest county has concluded that Joe Biden did in fact receive more votes than Donald Trump. A GOP-led review of the 2020 election in Arizona's largest county has concluded that Joe Biden did in fact receive more votes than Donald Trump. According to NPR, a hand recount of the nearly 2.1 million ballots cast in Maricopa County confirmed the results previously approved by county leaders. According to NPR, a hand recount of the nearly 2.1 million ballots cast in Maricopa County confirmed the results previously approved by county leaders. The new count showed that Biden actually exceeded the county's tally by 99 votes, while Trump received 261 fewer votes than the official results. The new count showed that Biden actually exceeded the county's tally by 99 votes, while Trump received 261 fewer votes than the official results. On September 23, Randy Pullen, a spokesman for the election review, confirmed the validity of the draft, saying, , "It's not the final report, but it's close.". On September 23, Randy Pullen, a spokesman for the election review, confirmed the validity of the draft, saying, , "It's not the final report, but it's close.". The news comes less than 24 hours before a scheduled presentation of the results in the Arizona state Senate. What has been found is both encouraging and alarming. On the positive side there were no substantial differences between the hand count of the ballots provided and the official canvass results for the county, Election Review Draft, via NPR. This partisan effort in Arizona appears to be ending the same as it begun — highly biased, incompetent individuals running the process, delay after delay after delay, and very importantly, completely un-transparent, David Becker, founder of the Center for Election Innovation and Research, via NPR. NPR reports that Trump and his allies have latched on to the Arizona audit as evidence that the 2020 election was rigged. According to NPR, the Maricopa report puts Republican claims of fraud to rest

Here’s what they found in Idaho:

l In Camas County, the webpage asserted that 27 of Trump’s votes shifted over to Biden. In the recount, the secretary of state’s office found no change in Biden’s tally and one additional vote for Trump.

l In Butte County, Lindell’s webpage claimed 58 of the former president’s votes wound up in Biden’s column. The recount found no new votes for Biden, but Trump got nine more.

l Bonner County was accused of handing over 1,122 of Trump’s votes to Biden. When they sampled nearly 7,700 votes — roughly 29 percent of all the ballots cast — the secretary of state’s office found an undervote of nine ballots that were too light for the scanners to pick up. That’s a discrepancy of less than one-tenth of 1 percent. It added one vote for Biden and eight for Trump.

“While I generally agree with Mike Lindell’s focus on massive vote fraud in six-plus key states, his facts regarding Idaho quite miss the mark,” Bonner County Clerk Michael W. Rosedale wrote. “Well, completely miss the mark.”

All of which raises the question: If Lindell can be so wrong about electoral terrain we know sufficiently well to verify, why would anyone take it on faith that he’s right anywhere else?

When you throw in all the court rulings and all the recounts — including the politically motivated session in Arizona — that support last fall’s election result, don’t you think it’s time to admit Biden won? — M.T.